Liberty Ballers: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Along The Olentangy for Ohio State Fans!

Power Forward: Reggie v. Speights

In case you haven't heard, Thaddeus Young is going to miss at least 2-3 weeks. This leaves the Sixers without their second leading scorer since the all-star break and their starting power forward (contrary to what Jimmy Fallon says).

Many questions surface in regards to "Baby Legs" twisted ankle. Will he be back for the playoffs? Should the Sixers shut him down? Who's going to pick up the slack? And who's going to start at the four during Thad's absence? 

The question I'm going to focus on for the time being is, who's going to start at the four? If last night was any indication, we can expect to see Reggie Evans and his beard rollin' with the starters. Is this a good thing? A bad thing? The general consensus in Sixerland is "Start M16!" I'm the biggest Marreese Speights supporter there is. That's why it might surprise you that I disagree.

Here's 2 reasons Reggie Evans should get the nod (more why Speights shouldn't):

1. Experience

Marreese Speights is a rookie. Do we really want to go into the playoffs with a rookie in the starting lineup? You might say, "Well last year Thad started," and you'd be correct. The difference being, Thad already had 22 starts under his belt, and played significantly better as a starter. Speights has started twice this season and has shot more than 10 percent below his season's average. He also doubled his turnovers in just four extra minutes of play.

Before you (John) get all over me about a small sample size, consider this. In the two games M16 has started he did three things Thaddeus never did as a rookie.

  • Looked and played nervous
  • Forced shots
  • Failed to play a lick of defense
Starting seven-year veteran Reggie Evans would allow Speights to play within his comfort zone which is, coming off the bench.

 

2. Rotations

Starting Speights would take away one of the Sixers biggest offensive weapons off the bench. This would make the already streaky second unit more likely to have scoring draughts. 

Say Speights does start. The offense would be effective for the first nine minutes, with M16 shouldering Thad's scoring load. But what would happen when the second unit came in? Here's potential lineups:

PG - Ivey

SG - Lou

SF - Iggy/Rush/Marshall

PF - Reggie/Marshall

C - Theo/Reggie

Look at those possibilities and tell me where the offense would come from. We all know Lou's capable of going off and carrying the offense. However; 75 percent of the time he resorts to, dribbling 20 seconds off the shot clock, forcing difficult shots, or throwing jump-passes.

If Marreese plays with the second unit, things change. Brining him off the bench doesn't guarantee that the offense won't stall and blow leads like they normally do, but odds are Speights helps the second unit's half-court offense much more than Reggie does.

 

That's why I'd rather see Reggie's beard in the startling lineup rather than M16. It has nothing to due with who's a better player, and has everything to do with balance between the starting lineup and the second unit. Think back to the arguments of why Lou shouldn't start -- don't want to lose that spark off the bench. The same goes for Marreese Speights.

The question shouldn't be, "Who should replace Thad in the starting lineup?" It should be, "Which unit takes less of a blow when Reggie's inserted -- the starting lineup or the second unit?"

Speights biggest asset is his offense, and tell me which four-man lineup needs more offense more...

  • Ivey, Lou, Iggy and Theo
  • Miller, Bill Green, Iggy and Sam

Just for kicks, check out last night's +/- combos after the jump.

Star-divide

 

From last night's game:

Lou/Speights +/- (+3)

Lou/Reggie +/- (-4)

----------

Sammy/Speights +/- (+1)

Sammy/Reggie +/- (-2)

----------

Theo/Speights +/- (+11)

Theo/Reggie +/- (DNP)

----------

3 or more starters/Speights +/- (+6)

3  or more starters/Reggie +/- (-6)

 

0 recs  |  Comment 6 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Forgot to mention.

When it comes to crunch-time, this all goes out the window. Speights needs to be on the floor in the fourth quarter, and Reggie doesn’t. Plain and simple.

by Jordan Sams on Apr 1, 2009 5:17 PM PDT reply actions  

Oh, and even with Reggie starting.

It should be a Bill Green situation — start the first and third quarters, and that’s it.

Speights should get the bulk of the minutes.

by Jordan Sams on Apr 1, 2009 6:50 PM PDT up reply actions  

Here's my problem with this logic.

Even with Speights out there with the second unit, let’s say:

Williams
Ivey
Iguoadala
Speights
Ratliff

They still suck offensively. Now, when you add Reggie to the starting lineup,

Miller
Green
Iguoala
Reggie
Dalembert

They suck offensively too.

I’d rather have one efficient lineup to work with than worry about balancing out how badly they suck between two. Make the second unit your pressure defense/slow the game down unit if you have to with Lou, Ivey, Iguodala/Marshall, Evans, Theo. But let’s have a shot at efficient offense with one of the units. I say start Speights with Sammy up front next to him, puts him on the easier cover, and Sammy’s rebounding should help hide Speights a little.

Send GT Green packing.

by depressedfan on Apr 1, 2009 7:55 PM PDT reply actions  

It'll be interesting to see how it plays out.

If Speights is in the startling lineup there’s no guarantee he’ll make them efficient. It all depends on which Speights shows up. If he settles for jump shots and forces things, he could end up hurting the offense. And prior to last night, he wasn’t himself, and actually sucked on both ends. This isn’t the same Speights that was dominating earlier in the season, this is the Speights who’s shooting 46 percent since the break.

He also seemed nervous the last two times he started. Why not relieve him of the pressure of being in the starting lineup and let him work out of his comfort zone? Him and Lou have had great chemistry together all year.

You can make a valid argument either way.

Me personally, would like to see it handled like the Green/Williams situation — Green starts, Williams finishes.

Gimme a crunch-time lineup of:

Miller
Lou
Iggy
Speights
Sam/Theo

And bottom line, that’s all I care about.

by Jordan Sams on Apr 1, 2009 8:13 PM PDT up reply actions  

Fair enough.

I just have trouble seeing a playoff team trot out a starting lineup that includes both Willie and Reggie. It’s embarrassing.

Send GT Green packing.

by depressedfan on Apr 1, 2009 10:02 PM PDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Liberty Ballers, the SB Nation blog for the Philadelphia 76ers, where you can't handle the Jruth.
Start posting about the 76ers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Lou Williams-the story of underappreciation
Small
Off-Topic: Team USA and is Coach K kidding the country?
Small
Basketball theory: The Sixers
Qlpk0etqwelv8artgc7tvqefu_small
Iguodala All-Star? or Turner Rookie of Year?
Small
76ers Place in the Eastern Conference Pt 2
Small
Amar'e in Israel
Small
nba and market
Small
76ers Place in the Eastern Conference Pt. 1
Small
So there's a God after all
Small
Why Bother?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Straight Cash Homie

Liberty Ballers

SBNation.com Recent Stories

NEW YORK CITY NY - AUGUST 12:  Kevin Durant #5 looks on during the World Basketball Festival USAB Showcase at Radio City Music Hall on August 12 2010 in New York City. (Photo by Chris Trotman/Getty Images for Nike) +4 updates

FIBA World Championships 2010: Team USA Routs Iran 88-51, Clinches Top Spot In Group B

Cleveland Cavaliers' Delonte West, right, shoot over Indiana Pacers' Jeff Foster in the first half of a NBA basketball game in Indianapolis, Monday, April 13, 2009.  (AP Photo/Michael Conroy) link

Celtics Sign Free Agent Delonte West

Rose +2 updates

FIBA World Championships 2010: Team USA Ekes Out 70-68 Win Over Brazil

More from SBNation.com >


Marky Marks

Picture_3_small Jordan Sams

Sharone_wright_sixers_small Michael Levin

The Funky Bunch

Turner3_small Tanner Steidel

Twitter_small Derek Bodner